You are currently viewing an archival version of GF!

Click here to return to the current GamesFirst! website.


GF! Archival Version Copyright 1995-2004

star06.gif (4104 bytes)star06.gif (4104 bytes)star06.gif (4104 bytes)  

by Activision

Great graphics, Impressive scope

Downs:  Bugs and stability problems, Questionable AI, Simple strategy 

System Reqs: P200 w/ 3D graphics card,  P266 w/o 3D graphics card, 32 MB RAM, 600 MB HD

The folks that made Star Trek: Armada have obviously been playing Starcraft and many of its more successful real-time strategy brethren, for Armada uses all the right bits and pieces from the genre and throws them into one game. Unfortunately, all the best ideas thrown together don’t make the best game. Armada is littered with problems big and small, and together make the game often as frustrating as it is fun. If it weren’t for these issues it may have been one of the best RTS’s to come out this year--but it's not.

The story is that everyone’s favorite space thespian, Captain Picard, must thwart a Borg invasion of the Alpha Quadrant headed by his old pal and vinyl wearing look-alike Locutus. Meanwhile, Whorf deals with a hostile coup to the Klingon throne, and--not to be ignored--those nefarious Romulans are wheeling and dealing with another superweapon. You are to take on these problems in twenty-some-odd missions with thirty plus units at your disposal.

Armada consists of four campaigns--one Federation, one Klingon, one Romulan, and one Borg. These must be completed in order and lead to a final showdown level in the Alpha Quadrant. All of the Races are very evenly matched--in fact, they're so much alike that there isn’t enough difference between them to make for very many interesting variations in strategy. This is rather disappointing as this game, and its subject matter, could easily accommodate  some pretty wild strategic funk. The gather-build-attack model is very basic--get dilithium to build everything, save for the use of officers and crew in manning your ships and structures. Transporter technology offers the possibility of boarding ships whose shields are down and attempting to physically commandeer the ship for your own use. But this ability is the only real original strategy here.

Armada doesn’t disappoint with its graphics. Damage effects, shields, and special weapons are as fun to watch as to use. And despite the fact that the game takes place exclusively in outer space, the maps never get boring. Instead of land obstacles such as mountains and water, you navigate around asteroid fields, nebulae, stars, and planets. Often the most challenging aspects of a level were finding a route through fast moving asteroid belts on their far flung orbits or taking advantage of defensively useful nebulae in order to bide your time against numerically superior enemies. Wormholes are scattered around and can transport you to the far edges of the map, and getting a good idea of the placement of the wormholes can make of break a level.

The interface used in Armada should be very familiar to anyone who has spent any time with realtime strategy games in the last couple years.  Not to flog a dead horse any harder, but it’s remarkably similar to Starcraft’s interface. Newbies as well as veterans of RTS’s will have little difficulty figuring out anything here.

The voice talents of Patrick Stewart, Michael Dorn, and Denise Crosby are used in the game. This will no doubt thrill Trekies and Trekers (shameless plug: if you have not yet seen a Klingon order a Big Mac go rent Trekies tonight). The cut scenes are really impressive, and serve to flesh out the rather confusing plot.

The biggest problem with Armada is its distinct lack of polish; it probably should have remained with the developers another month or two. Worst of all is its stability. In fact, I haven’t seen a more crash-happy major release in a long time. Those with NVIDIA graphics cards, like me, get the worst of it. The Esc key often serves as a game terminator and pressing the space key during boot up will kick you back on to your desktop and quit the game (I have no idea how I figured that one out). The v1.1 patch will fix the crashing and the random freezing, but a few problems still remain. There are a number of graphical glitches that can ruin the mood, especially after the great cut sequences. Other nagging problems included super-slow mouse movement and some questionable AI. The combination of these two caused me to cuss a little, especially when my ships were directed to a certain spot on the map and ended up turning around to fight without direct orders.

For the Star Trek fan, this game is the best shot yet at bringing to life the diverse elements that make up the Star Trek saga--and one of the best games based on it yet. But for those who don’t get a kick out of Klingons, and can probably do without the super-confusing plot obviously made for Trek die-hards, you might as well get out your trusty old Starcraft disc and log onto Battlenet.

--Thomas Hoff